Dealing with plagiarism is one of my least favourite aspects of academic life. Today’s case, however, is much more fun. And as it doesn’t concern any of my own students, it involves no additional admin. That’s already a win.
Yesterday I came across a sentence, that I once wrote in a paper for the Journal of Historical Geography, attributed to somebody else in the Guardian. To be honest, my surprise was not that someone had lifted my expression than that they had actually read my obscure paper about Rockall in JHG. I’ll take all the readers I can get.
The purported author of the sentence is Nick Hancock – a Fellow of the Royal Geographical Society – who is going to live on Rockall for over two months in 2013 (plenty of time, one might think, to reflect on appropriate attribution).
Hancock is an ‘adventurer’ – or, when he’s not wearing a dayglo drysuit, an Edinburgh property surveyor – who is aiming to break the record for the longest occupation of this unwelcoming rock. As Hancock intends to be there for 60 days, living in what looks like a yellow septic tank lashed to the rock, I guess the obvious question is: why?
Rockall Solo is rather hazy on this, aside from a bid to raise money for the forces charity Help for Heroes which, Nick tells us, “does not seek to criticise or be political” but rather to simply support “those wounded in the service of our country since 9/11”. Founding patron: Jeremy Clarkson.
This theme of heroism takes us back to another rationale as articulated in my purloined sentence (from MacDonald, 2005: 632), now oddly turned into a tagline on Nick’s personal website:
“To have visited Rockall was the epitome of heroism and reflected well on the bravery and moral character of the traveller”

A painting from Rev. W. Spotswood Green, Narrative of the cruise introducing notes of Rockall Island and Bank, Transactions of the Royal Irish Academy 31, 3 (1896) 39-97, p. 46.
And here is the nub of it. In my paper (here: pdf 0.4mb) , I detail the slow emergence of a scientific professionalism that sought to distance science from mere thrill-seeking. At the same time, however, I argued that scientific accounts of Rockall were interesting in that they showed how science still retained the influence of the sublime – a bourgeois male aesthetic that celebrated heroism.
In the original paper, I was not trying to say that Rockall’s early explorers were a cut above the rest (splendid chaps – all of them). Rather, I meant that inside the paternalistic and imperial values of Victorian society, a landing on Rockall was to enact the perceived virtues of manly science.
In short: it was an argument about class and gender in the making of scientific knowledge; it’s definitely not an endorsement – not then, and not now.
If all of this sounds a bit grumpy, this is less about missing footnotes than about a wider complaint I have about the modern expeditionary culture that is shared among many of the non-academic members of the Royal Geographical Society. Many favour old-fashioned ‘discovery’: the search for geographical knowledge providing the scientific legitimacy for getting there first or staying there longest (for which read: secure the territorial claim).

The British annexation in 1955: Corporal A. A. Fraser watches First Lieutenant Commander Desmond P. D. Scott hoist the Union Flag on 18th September
And to be honest, there isn’t much discovery on Rockall Solo. The scientific rationale is, at best, wafer thin.
It was always thus. When naturalist James Fisher helped the British state annex Rockall in 1955 he used science to authorize a brazen geopolitical claim, all so that Britain could test its shiny new nuclear missiles over the Atlantic.
British Prime Minister Sir Anthony Eden, who that same year was to be found bombing his way through the Mau Mau rebellion in Kenya, could be afforded this small advance amid a worldwide imperial retreat.
As I established in the paper, Rockall was the last ever territorial extension of the British Empire. All 83 feet of it.
This leaves Nick Hancock FRGS as just one of a long line of British occupiers – James Fisher, Andy Strangeway, Tom McClean – bearing the Union Jack and asserting the values of military heroism.
I don’t really mind the odd moment of bibliographic forgetfulness. But I find it much harder to overlook the pith-helmeted patriotism. After all, if the British claim to Rockall is so well founded, surely the rituals of discovery – settlement, flag-waving – are all a bit beside the point? Just ask the wildlife.

© Steve Bell If… 1985 The Guardian
Fraser, I was unaware that the quote was attributable to you, having not read your paper. I came across it during my research into Rockall on one of the many websites with information about the rock. I shall correctly attribute this to you, and read your paper, asap.
That’s no problem Nick. Thanks for being so honest. Alas it means that this paper has had even fewer readers.
Academic writing is pretty hopeless: only read by a handful of other pointy-heads. The research for the paper and the wider rocket range story (which I’m writing as a book) has required visits to several different archives over many years. So when other websites reproduce it without any acknowledgment, that can be frustrating. I hope your trip goes well.
[…] In his own blog, MacDonald asks why Hancock might want to lash himself to that rock for 60 days in “what looks like a yellow septic tank”. He reckons Hancock is hazy about this, apart from his bid to raise funds for the military charity Help for Heroes. […]
… [Trackback]…
[…] Find More Informations here: frasermacdonald.com/occupy-rockall-on-plagiarism-patriotism-and-heroic-science/ […]…
The Birch of the Shadow…
I think there may possibly be a several duplicates, but an exceedingly handy listing! I have tweeted this. Lots of thanks for sharing!…
… [Trackback]…
[…] Find More Informations here: frasermacdonald.com/occupy-rockall-on-plagiarism-patriotism-and-heroic-science/ […]…
Whispering Misty…
So sorry you are going to miss the workshop!…
Addison…
As I website owner I think the content here is really great, regards for your efforts….
Appreciate You Sharing…
I am really so much pleased for this terrific blog. Really thanks a ton! Will read on……
Thorn of Girls…
mothoExcellent information could be discovered on this world wide web blog site….
The authoritative message :), funny……
I apologise, but it absolutely another. Who else, what can prompt?…
Just Browsing…
While I was surfing yesterday I noticed a excellent article concerning…
Just Browsing…
While I was surfing yesterday I saw a excellent post concerning…
The Silent Shard…
This will likely likely be quite helpful for a few of your respective job opportunities I intend to do not only with my web site but…
Muchos Gracias…
Thank you so much for this amazing blog article. In fact looking forward to reading more. Great….
The Ships’s Voyages…
I feel know-how just makes it worse. Now there’s a channel to under no circumstances treatment, now there will not become a prospect for them to find out….
…Additional Information ca be found here…
..[…]…
… [Trackback]…
[…] Find More Informations here: frasermacdonald.com/occupy-rockall-on-plagiarism-patriotism-and-heroic-science/ […]…
buy azithromycin for chlamydia…
[…]zmax azithromycin[…]…
Brady Pooschke…
Brady Pooschke…
Terific Article…
I just cannot really appreciate it enough for this fantastic blog. Really thanks a ton! Great….
Pizza is a Favorite Food of Many…
[…] and making the kitchen fun is his goal. To learn more about the history of pizza in America and what makes good pizza visit his website. Category: Internet Marketing Tag: cookig tips cooking pasta, kitched advice […]…
The Birch of the Shadow…
I think there may possibly become a several duplicates, but an exceedingly handy checklist! I’ve tweeted this. Quite a few thanks for sharing!…
…A Friend recommended your blog…
[…]you made running a blog glance[…]…
Informative and precise…
Its difficult to find informative and precise info but here I found…
…Additional Information ca be found here…
[…]Nice blog here! Also your website a lot up fast![…]…
Gabriel…
I have been exploring for a bit for any high-quality articles or weblog posts in this kind of house . Exploring in Yahoo I ultimately stumbled upon this web site. Studying this information So i’m satisfied to exhibit that I’ve a very excellent uncann…
Commendable Blog Article…
I simply just enjoyed this extraordinary blog post. Certainly looking forward to read more. Impressive….
Healing’s Dragon…
to uncover difficulties to further improve my web site!I suppose its okay to create use of a few of your principles!!…
… [Trackback]…
[…] Read More Infos here: frasermacdonald.com/occupy-rockall-on-plagiarism-patriotism-and-heroic-science/ […]…
… [Trackback]…
[…] Find More Informations here: frasermacdonald.com/occupy-rockall-on-plagiarism-patriotism-and-heroic-science/ […]…
Anthony…
I have been browsing on-line more than three hours these days, but I by no means found any fascinating article like yours. It is beautiful value enough for me. In my view, if all web owners and bloggers made excellent content as you did, the internet w…
Keep Reading…
Very informative blog post. Want a lot more….
nice…
I enjoy, lead to I discovered exactly what I was taking a look for. You have ended my 4 day long hunt! God Bless you man. Have a great day. Bye…
The Ships’s Voyages…
I feel technological innovation just makes it even worse. Now there’s a channel to hardly ever care, now there wouldn’t become a probability for them to find out….
Recommeneded websites…
[…]Here are some of the sites we recommend for our visitors[…]……
Woman of Alien…
Best get the job done you might have completed, this great site is basically great with fantastic info. Time is God’s way of maintaining almost everything from taking place at once….
Visitor recommendations…
[…]one of our visitors recently recommended the following website[…]……
Recent Blogroll Additions……
[…]usually posts some very interesting stuff like this. If you’re new to this site[…]……
Tumblr article…
I saw someone writing about this on Tumblr and it linked to…
Awesome website…
[…]the time to read or visit the content or sites we have linked to below the[…]……
Cool sites…
[…]we came across a cool site that you might enjoy. Take a look if you want[…]……
Cool sites…
[…]we came across a cool site that you might enjoy. Take a look if you want[…]……
Great website…
[…]we like to honor many other internet sites on the web, even if they aren’t linked to us, by linking to them. Under are some webpages worth checking out[…]……
Digg this…
While checking out DIGG yesterday I noticed this…
Gems form the internet…
[…]very few websites that happen to be detailed below, from our point of view are undoubtedly well worth checking out[…]……
Google…
[…]usually posts some pretty intriguing stuff like this. If youre new to this site[…]…
Websites you should visit…
[…]below you’ll find the link to few sites that we think you could visit[…]……
Recommeneded websites…
[…]Here are some of the sites we recommend for our visitors[…]……
Websites you should visit…
[…]below you’ll find the link to some sites that we think you should visit[…]……
Wikia…
Wika linked to this place…
Recent Blogroll Additions……
[…]usually posts some very interesting stuff like this. If you’re new to this site[…]……
Informative and precise…
Its hard to find informative and accurate info but here I noted…